Security Risks, Segregation Likely to Undermine Afghan Election’s Legitimacy
Participation Expected to Be Uneven
Claims by Afghan President Hamid Karzai’s brother Wali that the government had reached a secret ceasefire with the Taliban to allow for safe voting across Afghanistan appears to have been premature; in both small villages and major cities potential voters are considering the serious dangers of voting in the election.
The risks are not just the vague prospect of a bombing at some polling place somewhere. Militants have made it a point to announce that anyone caught with an inked finger, a sign they voted in the election, will have that finger cut off.
Officials have conceded that violence may force some polling places to close early, and in many Taliban-heavy portions of the nation, polls won’t open in the first place. This is likely to keep the vote amongst Pashtuns, the nation’s largest ethnic group, artificially low.
And even in places where the vote will be held, a severe shortage of female staff and the official segregation of voting by gender is expected to keep much of the nation’s female population from voting as well. The US has said the appearance of legitimacy in this week’s vote is exceedingly important to the ongoing war effort, but if most of the nation is unable to vote, it seems impossible to imagine how the result can be spun as legitimate.
Last 5 posts by Jason Ditz
- Homegrown US 'Terror Plots' Drop, But Nation Still 'On Edge' - February 9th, 2012
- Amputations Soared Among US Troops in 2011 - February 9th, 2012
- US Still Can't Find Missing Libyan Missiles - February 9th, 2012
- Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood: Let Us Form Government - February 9th, 2012
- As Reports of Violence Grow in Syria, So Do Western Calls for Intervention - February 9th, 2012





Robert_Noval
August 17th, 2009 at 5:14 am
Get real.
You know this "election" will be deemed a "success", regardless of what happens.
If Florida '00 and Ohio '04 could pass for "legitimate", then the adverse circumstance of Afghanistan '09 will serve as basis for grading on a curve.
—The Bikemessenger