President Trump issued a statement on Thursday morning canceling the historic June 12 summit with North Korea’s Kim Jong-un. The statement thanked Kim for releasing American “hostages,” and bragged about America’s “massive and powerful” nuclear arsenal.
Trump cited recent comments out of North Korea as showing “tremendous anger and open hostility,” saying it would be inappropriate to attend the Singapore summit. He said a future summit was still possible, and invited North Korea to “call or write” if they want to try it again.
This puts a cap, at least temporarily, on four months of diplomatic overtures by North Korea, starting with the Winter Olympics. After the first overtures toward South Korea, the process quickly picked up pace, with Trump praising North Korea’s efforts, and ultimately agreeing to a direct meeting with Kim.
South Korea also had a summit, in which President Moon met with Kim. That summit went extremely well, centering on an ultimate deal to end the Korean War, which began in 1950. The US and China both gave support to this idea.
North Korea also sought negotiations on a denuclearization deal for the Korean Peninsula. This was the main US goal, and seemed very possible. As recently as Wednesday, the US was paring back demands on the rate of denuclearization, conceding it would be hard for North Korea to do everything at once.
But in recent weeks, problems started cropping up. A joint US-South Korea exercise involving warplanes led North Korea to complain that they are concerned the two nations aren’t taking the diplomatic track seriously. South Korea had to talk President Trump out of a second exercise involving nuclear-capable bombers not long after.
North Korea’s doubts were exacerbated by John Bolton’s talk of a “Libya model,” which saw Libya give up its WMD equipment for diplomatic gains it never really received. Within a few years, NATO was attacking Libya, and Gadhafi was killed in the streets.
Trump added to these concerns by suggesting Kim would share Gadhafi’s fate if he didn’t go along with US demands. Mike Pence made things even worse, saying it wasn’t a threat but “more of a fact.”
North Korea responded by calling Pence’s comments “ignorant and stupid.” This was the last statement made, the night before Trump’s pullout, suggesting that North Korea’s comments on Pence may have informed his decision to kill the talks.
While Trump kept the door open to future talks, he’s also majorly damaged America’s position as a country that can be dealt with. In recent weeks his administration has reneged on the P5+1 nuclear deal with Iran, and has now backed out of a summit just a few weeks away for no obvious reason. This only adds to the view that the administration is capricious and that even when deals are reached, it’s an open question if the US will honor them.
To make matters worse, the talks were canceled mere hours after North Korea destroyed its nuclear testing site, which was supposed to be a confidence building measure for the summit. This again raises concerns the US are just trying to get North Korea to disarm before backing away from the talks.
The Trump administration just couldn’t stop with the hateful speeches about N Korea leading up to the meeting. Pence and Bolton are stupid people going on TV and talking trash. Now Trump pulls out because N Korea talks trash, what infantile diplomacy.
So much winning……..
He was right. I did get tired of all the winning.
Still waiting for affordable health care and jobs that pay a living wage.
Not an answer. Empowering DC isn’t going to lead to the result you think it will.
Good going VP Penice. Now South Korea is caught in an awkward position. All the good will gegstures between the two just went down the toilet.
There is one aspect to “Libya” which is rarely mentioned. The materials which Qaddafi handed over went to our Oak Ridge national laboratory for inspection. Does anyone believe that Kim would ever hand over a single of his nuclear bombs to go to Oak Ridge, Tennessee for our inspection? And any of his long-range rockets?
Of course Kim had to show “tremendous anger” instead of just showing anger. Everything with Trump is yuge or tremendous.
Talking about their leader getting sodomized by a bayonet in the streets and their country being bombed didn’t sit well with North Korea I guess. Minor details for Trump, Pence and Bolton.
Don’t think for a minute that this isn’t exactly what Bolton had in mind when he mentioned Libya. That was deliberate sabotage and Pence was in on it too. Trump got sucked into this deal because he’s as easy as play-dough to manipulate. He got sucked out for the same damn reason.
Our best hope now is that Moon sticks to the deal and America loses all influence on the peninsula. Blowback works both ways.
Moon is the only adult in the room right now, and has the most to lose if all hell breaks loose.
Something tells me Russia and China will have something to say about this.
American demands are too high. They don’t want peace and respect, they want the country.
Raimondo will explain it all to us. How the brilliant Trump gambit will pay great peace dividends any day now – or, how the innocent, pure as driven snow, Trump, man of good will, was deceived by the evil neocons.
Something like that, I’m sure.
That’s my general view of Raimondo’s approach these days, too … but in this particular case he might be right.
Historically and anecdotally, North Korea’s diplomatic approach has seemed to involve a lot of storming away from the table. Perhaps Trump saw that coming with Kim’s protest of the war games and decided to see what would happen if this time the US beat the North Koreans to that particular punch.
It might work or it might not. It also might be what he’s up to or it might not. But it’s not entirely unreasonable to think that that might be what’s going on.
Diplomatically, the Obama regime clearly took that approach with Iran — make big demands, then when Iran said “OK,” suddenly switch to new ones and call Iran unreasonable while marching away from the table. That let the US drag out the fake “Iran nuclear crisis” out for years until the rest of the P5+1 finally prevailed on the US to quit fucking around for about five minutes.
Good tactic. Create a situation that the other side can’t tolerate and then blame the other side. I also think it was the “Libya model” talk, more than the war games that caused NK’s reaction.
“perhaps trump saw that coming”..more likely, SK told the US that they would not participate in the exercises, forcing the US to cancel.
Pence ‘ “ignorant and stupid’ “. And while the negotiations, themselves, began to get more and more ignorant and stupid.
I guess aged minds never change! And neither has my own old mind changed yet.
Sure, Trump can still change it, but i do not expect it.
Maybe this is for the best… the US can’t be trusted to negotiate in good faith, so let Korea engage in real diplomacy with the many nations that want to build our collective security. Maybe there will be mutual protection pacts to guard against the numerous wars the US is preparing to start. Maybe China especially and other nations will finally divest from trading in dollars and holding US debt. The US is not capable of being a partner for peace at this time.