Yesterday, US District Court Judge Richard Leon ordered an end to NSA surveillance of Americans’ domestic phone records, saying the program was almost certainly unconstitutional and has to halt. He in particular ordered a half to the spying on one specific complainant, which the Justice Department argues would require scrapping the whole program.
This isn’t the first time a judge has panned the NSA program, and once again nothing will come of it, as an Appeals Court today announced that they are going to allow the NSA to keep the system in place through November 29, when it shifts to a nominally different format which itself wasn’t a subject of the ruling.
In both cases, the surveillance will be materially the same, though after November 29 the NSA will be depending on American phone companies collecting all of their customers’ data and sharing it with them, which was Congress’ mostly irrelevant “reform” of the scheme.
Leon conceded yesterday that his ruling wouldn’t impact the post-29th program, but said he believed it was important that the courts offer at least some decisive ruling on the old system. Ultimately, however, being grossly unconstitutional didn’t stop the program before, and probably won’t stop it going forward.
Last 5 posts by Jason Ditz
- US Plans to 'Counter' Russia and China in Africa - December 13th, 2018
- Bolton: Trump Won't Meet Putin While Russia Holds Ukrainian Ships - December 13th, 2018
- Turkey Builds Up Military at Syria Border for Planned Offensive - December 13th, 2018
- Israel to Approve Thousands of Unauthorized West Bank Settler Homes - December 13th, 2018
- Yemen Talks End With Ceasefire Agreed for Hodeidah - December 13th, 2018