Two separate poison gas attacks have been reported in northern Syria today, in the Idlib and Aleppo Provinces. The attacks appear unrelated, and the reports suggest they were launched by opposite sides, with one an attack launched by rebels against government-held parts of Aleppo, and another apparently by a Russian military helicopter.
Syria state media reported the attack in Aleppo, labeling it an attack by “terrorist groups” with artillery shells containing unspecified poison gas. At least five civilians were killed, and a number of others wounded. This was in addition to other civilians killed and wounded in shelling around Aleppo with conventional munitions.
The other attack, reported by the Syrian Civil Defense NGO, was in Saraqeb, in the Nusra Front-dominated Idlib Province, where locals reported a Russian attack helicopter dropped canisters containing gas, likely chlorine, on the area where another helicopter was downed earlier in the day. Dozens were reported wounded, but none killed.
Russia has issued a statement denying any use of poison gas on their part, accusing the local media of fabricating the entire story. In both cases details and evidence remain scant, and many claims of illegal use of chemical weapons are never verified.
The Russians don’t need to use chlorine but if they were going in to retrieve their helicopter they probably did use smoke along with tear gas. I doubt that if you have never been hit with tear gas before that you could tell the difference. I have been tear gassed many times and it’s not exactly fun but it’s not the same as claiming a true chemical attack. Although I do believe that it’s not supposed to be used in combat anymore. Stupid rule if you ask me, better to run people off with tear gas than bombs, which are completely legal.
I can see why CS might be mistaken for chlorine, especially if there was also green smoke deployed. That might even be an intentional mix to create the impression and scare people into getting the hell out of the area.
I’ve been tear-gassed many times, too. Not pleasant, but unless you have asthma or something or it’s in an enclosed space with flames, temporary and annoying rather than lethal.