UN Taliban-al-Qaeda Sanctions Monitoring Committee head and former British intelligence official Richard Barrett today warned that the US goals in Afghanistan were “incredibly hard” to achieve and that a way ought to be found to engage the Taliban politically.
“However many of them you kill, there’ll be more coming over the hill,” warned Barrett, adding that he thought the justification for Britain’s involvement in the war was “debatable.”
Barrett’s comments will likely add to the growing number of questions about the war strategy, as Pentagon officials maintain, despite all evidence to the contrary, that the military operations are going well.
But Barrett’s concerns aren’t military, but rather political, saying that the US goals require a political solution and that all the US has at its disposal are military means.
Defeating Germany and Japan was "incredibly" hard to achieve too. But at least it appeard to have a overall concept and plan as to how to defeat them. Even if it had to be adapted to realities on the ground the general flow of the war seemed to go toward the hoped for conclusion.
Afghanistan looks to be a jumble of "lets try this" NO OK "then lets try that". What is the goal? Is it to establish a governement in a place that has never really had such a thing for a long time? Is it oil or to surround Iran? I guess if we knew what the plan really was then we could see if its actually working but as it is it just looks like a mess.
So far as I can tell, the only way to 'defeat' the locals in Afghanistan is to do it the way the Mongols did in 1221: kill everybody. Like 'victory' in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, piles of corpses don't talk back. Tamerlane didn't have to fight an insurgency after he converted his new subjects into pyramids of human skulls. The char-broiled citizens of Dresden didn't bother anybody with claims of war crimes after IT happened. Go insane slaughter! – or stay home in the first place.
"Go insane slaughter! – or stay home in the first place" jejejeje
DO YOU MEAN, KEEP BEING INSANE ?? This kind of behavior is the most eloquent indication of the TOTAL DEGENERATION OF THE HUMAN CONDITION
"Go insane slaughter!"
If you're going that route, be prepaired and don't complain if you have
a lot more terrorisim on the domestic front.
Decades of liberal minded immigration from all over the world
to N. America, guarantees that once you start wholesale slaughter
of thier kin, abroad, they will retaliate, in your backyard.
All bets will be off, and so will any semblence of humanity,
as someone else has suggested.
M
Even the slaughter route is no sure thing in the era of sniper rifles and truck bombs. The Soviets sure weren't shy about mowing down people en masse in Afghanistan and it really didn't do them a lot of good.