Trump administration officials have announced measures to suppress protests on college campuses that are critical of Israel, steps that have chilling implications for First Amendment rights.
President Trump wrote on Truth Social that he would cut federal funding to colleges that allow “illegal protests,” a reference to the student-led pro-Palestine demonstrations that have spread across the country in response to Israel’s bombing campaign and siege on Gaza. The president also threatened that “agitators” would be imprisoned or deported if they were foreign students.
“All Federal Funding will STOP for any College, School, or University that allows illegal protests. Agitators will be imprisoned/or permanently sent back to the country from which they came. American students will be permanently expelled or, depending on the crime, arrested. NO MASKS!” the president said.
Elise Stefanik, Trump’s nominee to be ambassador to the UN, celebrated Trump’s announcement and acknowledged that the purpose of the order is to target protests against Israel.
“Under President [Trump], colleges and universities will be held accountable. Antisemitism and anti-Israel hate will not be tolerated on American campuses. Promises made, promises kept,” Stefanik said.
Journalist Glenn Greenwald, a constitutional lawyer, explained in a video posted on X why cutting federal funding over political speech and protests is a violation of the First Amendment.
“You can take the position that there should be no federal funding of universities or there should be, that’s independent of the free speech point,” Greenwald said. “Once the federal government or any government decides to offer a benefit that’s optional … it cannot then condition receipt of that benefit on your expressing a particular view, your affirming a particular view, or your refraining from expressing a political view. This is basic First Amendment doctrine.”
Trump’s announcement came a day after Robert F. Kennedy Jr., the secretary of Health and Human Services, announced HHS would be taking steps to combat “antisemitism” on college campuses in another directive aimed at pro-Palestinian protests. While both President Trump and his predecessor have labeled the protests “antisemitic,” many Jewish students and organizations have been involved in the demonstrations.
HHS said in a press release that it, along with the Department of Education and the US General Services Administration, will be launching a “comprehensive review of Columbia University’s federal contracts and grants in light of ongoing investigations for potential violations of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act” over allegations of antisemitism related to pro-Palestine protests.
“Antisemitism – like racism – is a spiritual and moral malady that sickens societies and kills people with lethalities comparable to history’s most deadly plagues,” Kennedy said in a statement. “In recent years, the censorship and false narratives of woke cancel culture have transformed our great universities into greenhouses for this deadly and virulent pestilence. Making America healthy means building communities of trust and mutual respect, based on speech freedom and open debate.”
Last week, Leo Terrell, an attorney leading the Department of Justice’s “Task Force to Combat Antisemitism,” vowed he would put “Hamas supporters” in jail. “You see all these disorderly demonstrations, supporting Hamas and trying to intimidate Jews? We are going to put these people in jail — not for 24 hours, but for years,” Terrell said in an interview with Israel’s Channel 12.
Terrell, whose task force was created by an executive order signed by President Trump in January, said indictments and other “aggressive” moves would begin soon. The DOJ said the task force would be visiting 10 college campuses to investigate alleged antisemitic incidents.
“When you see universities start losing millions of dollars in federal funding, you’re going to see a change in their behavior. When you see court orders protecting Jewish students, visas of antisemitic students being revoked — you will see a major change,” Terrell told Channel 12.
Back in 2019, President Trump signed an executive order directing all executive departments to consider the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s (IHRA) definition of antisemitism and the organization’s list of examples of “contemporary antisemitism” when enforcing Title VI of the Civil Rights Act.
The IHRA’s examples of “contemporary antisemitism” includes “drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis.” It also lists applying “double standards” to Israel by “requiring of it a behavior not expected or demanded of any other democratic nation” and “denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination” by “claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor.”
Max Blumenthal& @MaxBlumenthal
Members of the anti-woke commentariat that mocked the Biden CDC for declaring racism a "public health threat" are silent as Trump's HHS Secretary RFK Jr does the same with antisemitism – all to satisfy Zionist billionaire donors seeking to crush free speech
About 90% of "free speech champions" did a 180 after October 7th. I guess "freedom of speech" meant "freedom of speech we agree with" for them.
That's funny. But for some reason not as funny as NGOs that are actually not.
"…CDC for declaring racism a "public health threat…"
Lard tunderin', as if the CDC didn't have enough credibility issues already…
Knesset passes law mandating five years in jail for denial of October 7 massacre. https://www.timesofisrael.com/knesset-passes-law-banning-denial-of-october-7-massacre/
A Moroccan activist was sentenced to 5 years for criticizing the country’s ties to Israel. https://apnews.com/article/morocco-israel-palestinians-zankad-d924b81bb8096f9e593f0efebd30b90d
"If you want to know who rules over you, just look for who you are not allowed to criticize." — Voltaire
If nothing else, it I had become abundantly clear that the Republican and Democratic parties do not work for you any more than the CCP. Except the CCP doesn't try shut down Americans' speech
Constitution of the United States – First Amendment
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances. https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/amendment-1/
https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/a6b98e94c78b77baf9378587723ff1600686a2fd58815752800ec9ba7f7b7009.jpg
USA is hanging by a thread!!
“don’t murder me! I beg of you don’t murder me! Please…. Don’t murder me?!”
Good one, Donna. LOL. But you may want to think it through, sister. See… Since you can't have free speech in this situation, they would have to murder you. …My un-asked for advice? Tell them the Palestinians are just asking not to be murdered.
So much for freedom of speech the baboon trumpeted during his address to Congress.
"Baboon" reminds me of Emil Cosman name calling the pro-war party on You-tube.
Someone has to do it, so I will. What do you have against baboons?
Alas, nothing effective against that particular one.
baboon? Such labels damage your credibility.
I apologize. How about fuck*ng baboon?
How about ZERO credibility. 🙂
I agree. He has to stop complimenting Trump or I will change my mind about him.
Baboons and Humans share ~94% of their DNA. Trump's support for inhuman ASI genocidal policies dips him below 80% human.
Biden and all his administration and most of the House and Senate and the cabinet and all of the MSM. For whatever reason, and it is beyond me, Humans seem to be a very evil creation, but I cannot figure out why……..it is so very disturbing. 🙁
You're right, a lot of
baboonsfuck*ing baboons in the human race.I think it’s our advanced intellect that allows us, most out of all animals, to self-justify the terrible things we do to others.
Nothing so evil it can’t be reasoned as something good…
So you can protest your own government, but protesting Israel is “illegal”?
Will this country ever wake up and realize the entire U.S. Government is bought and paid for by the Zionists?
This is beyond ridiculous and absurd would be an understatement at this point.
Is my statement “illegal” as well? Will I be deported for making it? Will I still be treated for cancer by the VA after I’ve been deported?
I wonder how many in this so called government know what a D.D. 214 is?
Well at this point if you write this on YouTube you will simply be deleted or shadow banned so far. Lots of my comments show up on YouTube articles but almost none when it comes to the Middle East and Israel, yet I keep on typing. I call it putting out the energy.
You are right though with the new Exec order that Trump promised, comments like this may be forbidden by Anti-war as well.
What makes you believe that Trump will tolerate people protesting the US government?
Oh, that'll come after "illegal to protest corporate development projects" (oil pipelines & such) and "the US military may now break up protests on US soil", both of which are coming.
You have cancer ? Sorry to hear that – I hope you're winning your fight !!
Thank you. I’m still recovering from surgery. I’ll know more next month after another CT scan to see if my lungs are clear of adenocarcinoma (non-small cell lung cancer).
The United State of Israel is now extending to United Universities of Israel…! Shameful…!
Now in the free world that would be considered Dictatorship…!
Yesterday it was applauded by at lest half of the critters when Trump said that he will make it an Exec order.
Of course it is dictatorship. But as I mentioned at another article here, when things are really, really bad in a country it is always ripe for a dictator and over half of the citizens agree with it so far.
The last four years of the Democrats installing WEF adn old Soviet Union tyranny it is only a natural reaction to pull hard in the other direction. Trump knew this and took advantage from the start. Right up his alley where he can boss everybody around adn people call him a "a lovable king" appointed by god. And frankly the democrats are clueless, they are pushing down hard on the stuff they lost for like transgender stuff, pronouns, late term abortions, open borders. There are a few Liberals left in the Dem party who know and are pulling their hairs out that the Dems as a party are not learning a thing.
Democrats are devils, no changing that!
"But as I mentioned at another article here, when things are really, really bad in a country it is always ripe for a dictator and over half of the citizens agree with it so far."
—
Yes, the half that voted for Trump.
I guess Trump must be planning a third term after all. Otherwise, those people that told me Trump wouldn't be beholden to Israel because he couldn't run again were full of shit
Where, oh where is old JD when you need him defending our sacred free speech rights, indeed our unalienable rights to speech, here at home? Given his Munich speech, does he believe that the enemy of the American people is within, just like he stated is the case for the Europeans?
As for the nonsense trotted out to appease the fools, very very few of the college demonstrators were foreigners. Almost all are native born Americans. So this idiocy, like so much else in this Administration, is just posturing for the funders of the party.
If this kind of crap isn't UNCONSTITUTIONAL I don't know what would be. "The Freedom of Speech shall NOT be infringed" is enshrined in our Bill of Rights. At least it was. It supposedly is one of the pillars upon which our Free Republic rests. I suspect they know this is unconstitutional but hope to intimidate the students on campus. Imagine the government making a law to punish BLM protests on campus. There would be hell to pay.
Oh, their defense will be "students can still SAY what they're saying, we're just coincidentally yanking federal funding for those schools where such protests happen to take place."
It's "I'M not hitting you, YOU'RE hitting you" logic.
We all know who the real villains of the piece are. We're simply not allowed to say who they are, not even if we leave one or more letters out of their linguistic identifiers.
Hatred frequently originates in the suppression of the right to speak out in anger. Anger is a recognized part of free speech.
End of a democracy, not with a bang, but with a gag-muffled cry.