Among a series of different military equipment the Obama Administration provided to the Ukrainian military over the last year of ceasefire in the eastern civil war, the US gave the nation some 72 Raven RQ-11B micro-drones, surveillance drones worth an estimated $9 million.
Despite the US giving them the drones, and training them how to use them (which, in all fairness, mostly involves throwing the tiny “hand-launched” drones and then viewing an analogue video feed), Ukraine has a serious case of buyer’s remorse, or at least recipient’s remorse.
Ukrainian military officials say the drones have been a disappointment from the start, complaining that the eastern rebels have shown the ability to hijack the video feeds and even jam them more or less at will. Those familiar with the device say this is unsurprising, as the drones are analogue and thus don’t use any encryption to protect data.
Ultimately, Ukrainian officials say the drones took way too long to arrive, were not very useful, and they wished they could’ve returned them to the US, though naturally they can’t.
For their part, the US sought to blame Russia for their drones being lousy, insisting Russia’s electronic warfare capabilities are “sophisticated,” and presumably they have shared enough with the rebels to foil the drones.
Well ain’t that a freakin’ pity? The Ukrainians have had these drones for almost two years. They started using them at Shirokine in the days before the ‘withdrawal’ from Debaltsevo. Typical ‘learning curve’.
There drones are like other tools of COIN warfare. They work only against the most unsophisticated enemy. We designed them to use against helpless opponents.
Yes, it would be possible to make drones that could be used against a peer competitor. Our stealth drone, lost over Iran, may be one example, but we are not going to give that to someplace like Ukraine.
What we are willing to lose by handing it over to Ukraine won’t be good enough to work against the Russians are their proxy on their own border.
Hmmm, I’d expect that these will soon be surplus military gear given to police departments to use against US citizens who won’t have the capabilities to defend themselves. In fact, if its not already illegal to defend oneself from such a drone, it probably will soon be.