Much has been made in the past few weeks of the Obama Administration’s plan to issue a new nuclear weapons doctrine, replacing the Bush Doctrine that included the possibility of using nuclear weapons against non-nuclear states.
But while the Obama Administration is formally renouncing that option on the surface and claiming its arsenal is for “deterrence” only, it appears that the doctrine will include an enormous loophole that will mean the nominal policy shift will ultimately mean very little.
The loophole will insist that the only non-nuclear states free of preemptive nuking are those which are “in compliance with their nonproliferation obligations.” This would, at least from the administration’s perspective, leave open the possibility of attacking Iran with nuclear weapons.
Iran would certainly argue that they are in compliance, of course, but exactly what these obligations are is never altogether clear to the public (the IAEA safeguards agreements are not made public) and President Obama has made clear that he believes Iran is not.
At the end of the day this policy is only a guideline anyhow, and if the president decided to nuke Iran the after the fact argument of if they were really non-compliant will likely be very much beside the point. But while the president still claims to have a goal of a nuclear-free world, the manufacture of such a deliberate loophole for a nuclear first strike is beyond troubling.
Which is exactly why Iran needs to get some nukes….. if only to protect itself from the Great Satan
Too bad Serbia didn't have them in 1999.
This is NOTHING but more classic Obamian Orwellism. The 'new' strategy is so completely hedged that it's simply the 'old' strategy with glitter sprinkled over it. In fact, it solidifies nuclear impunity by sacralizing nuclear attacks currently under consideration (Iran, North Korea, Syria) as 'exceptions', 'outliers'. Notice how the terminologies of militarized fascism are converging. Extremists at home and outliers abroad need expect no rights, no mercy, no sympathy…
I'm with you guys, with this sort of sloppy thinking around, everyone needs realistic deterrence to keep the seekers of domination at bay…. Run your country, not OURS..!!!!
Nice loophole. Wouldn't want the US Federal Government to appear hypocritical.
More and more it is like being mired in quicksand and as we sink seeing a beautiful blue sky above us and knowing that we will never see it again.
What blue sky?
It's usually covered with chemtrails…
I was using the blue sky figuratively as a representation of all that we have lost and are losing and the horrible impression that what is lost will never come back.
It seems a new world order is being made. A spinned one. People are spinned into agreeing with their political and military leaders. So I suggest your American Empire should be depicted not by an eagle, but a gigantic black spider sitting at the top of the globe.
"Changed spin, you can believe in, while continuing to obey your masters."
Historically, what came after the classic Greek democracy, with its sophism (another spin type of regime), was NOT truth and honesty – Aristotle was just a short glimpse before the new times – but instead WITHDRAWAL from, and DISTRUST in, the world. In the form of STOICISM. Because people still needs some truths to hold to, after all, as humans.. And I prophecy our times will be seen eventually as the great age of WASTE. Of work, production, mind.. A LOWER and more MISERABLE form of life than was fitting for humans. No dignity, respect, consistence, meaning. The great, dark Age of Spider Surveillance. Or ASS, as you Americans – with usual love for snappy abbreviations – might label your empire 🙂
Montaigne, Stoicism is about self-control and reason, not withdrawal and distrust. I agree though with your assertion that this age will be seen as a very dark one. Which is why we need self-control and reason all the more to see us through. Eventually the Spider State will be brought into the light and wither away or crushed under it's own weight. Though that leaves open the question of how many get hurt in the meantime. One can only weather the storm and hope for the best.
How about just nuke Israel. That would get rid of the worlds trouble maker and there would be peace for all.
I AGREE WITH YOU SIR………….1000% (A VIET NAM ERA VET,AIR FORCE)
Not only would it solve the problem, it would be fitting payback for the evils Israel has inflicted on its neighbors.
What a catastrophic mistake it was in 1948 to let that country be created through the conquest of Palestine. Every year this becomes more and more clear.
You know what's disgusting? Purportedly antiwar people casually, joyfully even, advocating the nuking of tons of innocent people.
choclate is good for hearts.if you want to loose some kilo,soya is best .if you wants better mental case,stay away of nukes.
Wait a minute…I thought it McCain who sang "bomb bomb bomb Iran" ? I thought only the republicans were for that sort of thing?
just imagine,this person got a nobel prize.
He won that prestigious award for the great achievement of not being Bush
As it should be; thus freeing Planet Earth to cleanse itself of human pestilence.
obomber IS the most deadly liar- others lie , but the war criminal in chief is in the power place to be able to nuke anyone in the way of fascist amerikan imperialism !
tioche, Mexico
Sitting in Sweden and have just heard the evening news on so-called public service Program 1. It's more like a cerebral pogrom. We don't have an Amy Goodman ; we have PBS bull shit. They naturally didn't mention the loophole. Well, if Obama wants the option of the ultimate in state terrorism, he's got it. He had better know that any initial successes will soon be overshadowed by the consequences of opening Pandora's box. He needs some good advice from the great Israeli peace activist , Uri Avneri. Someone, please ! Get Avneri's phone number to Obama before it's too late. I'm not kidding.
You're in Sweden? Hey tell them thanks for the peace prize!
Mr. "Nuke 'Em" Nobel Prize winner is clearly a raving lunatic. I wonder when Code Pink will do a "die in" at the Capitol in protest. Nah!…. Their nuclear savior is at the button, why bother!
IS THIS THE EXTENDED HAND THAT OBAMA IS TALKING ABOUT?
Extended hand? More like extended middle finger.
Iran and every freedom and liberty loving Nation needs nuclear weapons as deterrence against Anglo-American Terrorist Organization and coalition of Satraps.