The US military could end a mission to facilitate aid shipments into Gaza using a temporary pier as early as next month, the New York Times reported, citing Pentagon officials. The pier has faced constant problems since it was first established in May, including rough weather that has resulted in damage and shutdowns.
While the Joe Biden administration expected the pier to last into September, when choppy seas would make it inoperable, unnamed officials told NYT the mission could come to and end much sooner, warning aid groups that it could close down by July.
Last Friday, the Pentagon announced that the structure would be towed to Ashdod, Israel to avoid inclement weather, the second time it was withdrawn to the city due to high seas. The Defense Department has said the pier would return to the Gaza coast sometime this week, and while officials told the Times the causeway could soon be dismantled, DoD spokesman Patrick Ryder stressed that “there is no indication right now that there are plans to stop using the pier to deliver aid.”
Though US officials have touted the pier as a way to deliver much-needed supplies to Gazans amid Israel’s months-long bombing campaign, some humanitarian orgs have slammed the project as a farce. In late May, Michael Selby-Green, a media spokesperson for Islamic Relief, told the New Arab the effort was merely a “distriction,” noting that even at full capacity it could only cover a fraction of Gaza’s needs.
“It’s taken two-and-a-half months to build the pier and deliver the claimed 1,000 metric tonnes of aid, which is a drop in the ocean compared to what’s needed in Gaza. Every day that passes pushes more families closer to starvation and puts more lives at risk,” he added.
Doctors Without Borders’ director of communications in the UK, Sam Taylor, similarly described the pier as “an illusion of improvement,” while a spokesperson for the Norwegian Refugee Council called it an “an expensive, time-consuming and unviable option as an aid route in the long run.”
The US military has claimed that some 3,500 tons of aid has been delivered to Gaza using the makeshift pier, but aid groups say much of the supplies are not reaching those who need them, pointing to issues with security and logistics thanks to the ongoing war. According to the Times, the structure has facilitated just seven truckloads worth of aid per day, falling far short of an ultimate goal of 150 trucks, as well as the bare minimum of 500 trucks needed to sustain Gaza’s population.
Will Porter is assistant news editor at the Libertarian Institute and a regular contributor at Antiwar.com. Find more of his work at Consortium News and ZeroHedge.
A classic waste of money.
… he shoulda known, the only thing the military can do is the opposit of "build".
Indeed. The US should have said the aid is going in through land corridors and if you try to stop it, we will use force to get it through. But I bet that isn't why YOU think it was a waste of money.
"we will use force to get it through" AKA. Your pipe dream. The USA attacking Israel. Got any other crazy dreams?
Not even a pipe dream. I'm not stupid.
They knew it was junk when they signed the contract to build it in 2003, they knew it was junk when it was launched in 2007, they knew it was junk the only time it was used in 2013, and they knew it was junk before they ever sent it to the Mediterranean. I suspect the Pentagram hoped either the Israelis or Palestinians would sink it so they wouldn't have to maintain it any more.
I suppose Butcher Bibi has finally accepted that after a century of ethnic cleansing, dispossession and now famine and genocide the Palestinians are just not gonna leave Palestine, not by land or sea, outside of a coffin.
So he told Biden if he can't get some Palestinians on that good-for-nothing pos dock to get it off his land and out his waterways, he's got babies to decapitate, mothers to rape and prisoners to torture to death.
… and he better send those 2K bombs PDQ so he can finish the job on the Lebanonese Palestinians.
Yeah, and his competitor for the White House sez the same thing.
Miriem Edelson’s $100M catnip, eh? Just shows ya, under the skinThe Donald and Stormi are the same.
Wow, What a weird way of looking at things.
Reality is like that.
The pier to nowhere .
About time.
Pier-gate anyone? Demo-Rats: …Nah. He's a Demo-Rat. It's only a problem if he were a Repugninant. We don't care. Americans: Sure. We don't care either.
yeh, what's another $400M, right Joe, … and let the Zionazis sell the scrap.
I did Nasi that.
ouhhhhh, what is the policy on puns here?
NA is king of bad puns. I crowned him myself.
You can file a complaint with Wars or Spy on This.
Come on, man! You think I don’t know my International Rules Based Order by heart? It’s chapter 1, section 3, article a: “micro antisemitism”, levity in re a sacred zio-theme???
😂
The figure of $320m to build the pier was thrown around an awful lot, but the truth is the components were already built years ago, and sitting in a holding yard in Del Mar, CA, waiting to be taken somewhere and stitched together. We've had the Trident pier system for a long time, and it's always had problems. What are the odds that it will never be used for Gaza aid again, and what are the odds it will be turned over to the Israelis and repurposed to support the drill rigs that will soon appear off the coast of Gaza?
"what are the odds it will be turned over to the Israelis and repurposed to support the drill rigs" Zero. If the pier system can not be used to move food successfully, it certainly can not be used to move multi millions dollar heavy drill pipe and BOP equipment. Besides, the Hiafa port can handle the needs of drilling rigs. If there is a lot of gas/oil than the port can be expanded.
There's not, it's valued at only a few billion dollars and that's without the cost of extraction. It's believed that the gas off Gaza is already being extracted by slant drilling from other platforms within Israeli borders.
To obtain the natural gas for profit that was denied to the Palestinians in Gaza. The port that was destroyed years ago by Israel will be rebuilt. The airport that was destroyed years ago by Israel will likewise be rebuilt. Palestinians remaining alive will be relocated to a tent city in the Sinai Desert. To die.
The pier served it's purpose for operation Trojan Horse which recovered 4 captured setters and massacred a couple hundred natives. On to the next DC plan to support Israel!
Someone is still upset that 4 kidnapped victims were "recovered". LOL.
Someone is upset that 7,000 "detainees" (some as young as 10 years old) are still in Israeli jails.
One should be. Each freed hostage is one less bargaining chip to get the 7000 plus known terrorists released.
A 10-year-old is a "known terrorist". Hah. I thought Rational Thinker had cornered the market on dips**t racist assumptions, but nope, turns out you've got a few hundred pounds of the high-grade tucked under your mattress.
There are no 10 years old being held by Israel. As opposed to Kfir Bibas a nine month old baby taken by the Gaza terrorists on Oct 7. There are some 16 and 17 old Palestinians terrorists in training being held for launching fire bombs and rocks at IDF troops.
“The head of the Palestinian Prisoners' Club, Qadura Fares, said on Monday that since the war began, Israel has arrested 153 women in Gaza, including pregnant women and those who are being detained with their babies.”
https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-12-12/ty-article/.premium/israel-detained-153-gazan-women-some-with-babies-says-palestinian-prisoners-club-head/0000018c-5d37-d03f-af9f-7d772cdf0000
Israel has been detaining and imprisoning Palestinian children for decades and mostly using manufactured and trumped up charges and labeling everyone a terrorist.
”Since 2000, the Israeli military has detained some 13,000 Palestinian children, almost all boys between the ages of 12 and 17, said Defense for Children International-Palestine (DCIP).
"Everywhere a Palestinian child turns, there is the Israeli military to exert some kind of control over their life," said DCIP advocacy officer Miranda Cleland.
Based on collected affidavits from 766 children detained between 2016 and 2022, DCIP found about 59% were abducted by soldiers at night.
Some 75% of children were subjected to physical violence and 97% were interrogated without a family member or lawyer present. One in four are placed in solitary confinement for two or more days even before the beginning of a trial, said Cleland.
https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/palestinians-arrested-under-israeli-occupation-childhood-disrupted-2023-12-30/
You mean me ? 'Cause that describes me.
Not as mad as you are about the 100+ Israelis released last November without a single Palestinian killed in return! Just think how many thousands the US could have justified killing to rescue them!
You forgot the 3 hostages the "heroic" rescuers killed during the operation.
Or were killed by Hamas to prevent their rescue. In any case, Hamas is responsible for their deaths.
Israel did a rescue mission that was guaranteed to kill a large number of women and children. They knew because they created those conditions. It was their decision and theirs alone. And using your logic Israel would be responsible for those other 3 hostages getting killed if Hamas killed them. If they hadn't tried that reckless rescue mission, Hamas wouldn't have killed them.
It's "Hamas is always to blame" all the way down, with that one.
His hate for Hamas & Palestinians is in direct proportion to his fawning adoration of the Apartheid State of Israel.
Hamas took hostages and kept them in civilians area. AKA, A human shield. In this case those deaths are on Hamas.
Your hate for Israel clouds your judgement. I know you don't like it, but Israel has been around for 76 years and they will be around long after you are gone.
False, Timothy, patently false. If you'd but ASK I'd give you all the honest answers I can legally provide. As follows:
I don't "hate" Israel, and more than a person could "hate" prime numbers, four-dimensional timespace, or Tom Hanks.
A country is lines on a map. Could I "hate" Abyssinia (Henry), or Atlantis, or Prussia ? No.
A nation ? That is a collective culture, and like replicants- they're either a benefit or a hazard. If they're a benefit, it's not my problem. And few are ever a hazard. I don't know of any.
A state ? Like the governance and political machinations of the Apartheid State of Israel? I can certainly despise it, and I do, but not hate. It's still made up of humans and their ideas. Deeply flawed and misguided, but not worthy of hatred.
Israel, or Syria, or Moldova, or Benin…any country that can live peacefully within its own borders can do so. But if a State starts to act outside of modern social contracts, invading and suppressing and murdering (inside or outside it's imaginary-line borders) then the State must expect a response.
All I care about is the people; those the victim of another State, or victim of their own. The Palestinians are the former; Israelis the latter. That brilliant MCU quote about "the first country the Nazis invaded was Germany" is applicable…"the first country that Zionism ruined, was Israel."
Reckless rescue mission. That rescue mission save the lives of four Israelian citizens. Did it cost the lives of three others, we don't know.
As for the lost of civilians lives, that is what happens to human shields. They die. As Sinwar said, they are "necessary losses" .
Of course it was reckless. When the ratio of hostages to those innocents killed was that great, it can't be described as anything BUT reckless. And the fact that 3 out of 7 hostages were killed makes it even more reckless no matter who killed the other 3 hostages. And your human shield excuse is really poor since 7 of those human shields were hostages. And quoting Sinwar to justify Israel killing innocents is a new low even for a scum like yourself
Lard tunderin', Timmy, an Israeli could kill himself in Mexico and you'd hold Hamas somehow responsible.
Whoever killed the hostages is responsible for their deaths.
I'm very sorry to have to explain a simple tenet of Criminal Law 098 to what I assume is a grown adult.
This is not an American school shooting where pearl-clutching Justice Joe's and Jane's try to lay blame on the dead shooter's cousin's best-friend's co-worker's sister for once having shown the shooter a copy of "Guns & Ammo".
Whoever killed the victim is who was responsible.
Anything else is motivated witch-hunting.
And we already suspect your motivations and your "witches", Timmy.
Keep telling yourself that if it makes you feel better. The rest of the worldgot their proof of how Hamas cares for the hostages. Not only were they healthy and spent not one day in the hospital, but the hostages themselves speak of how they protected them from IDF bombing.
Move on or better yet, The IDF is looking for recuits
"Hamas cares for the hostages" You got any other jokes? "spent not one day in the hospital" True if you don't count Sunday or Monday as days. Noa Argamani, 26, was released on Tuesday afternoon.
And Amit Soussana will strongly disagree that Hamas cared for the hostages. Look up her reports on how she was treated.
Health Ministry says returned hostages to now be treated in separate ward, following criticism that Yocheved Lifshitz's public remarks after she was freed were a PR win for Hamas
The ministry unveiled the new guidelines a day after Yocheved Lifshitz, 85, described Tuesday at a widely attended press conference outside Tel Aviv’s Ichilov Hospital how her terrorist captors took her by motorcycle from Kibbutz Nir Oz to and into a “spiderweb” of tunnels in Gaza, while accusing Israel’s leadership of failures that made her and others into “scapegoats.”
She said her abductors beat her on the way to Gaza, but that she was treated well after that.
The event, with Lifshitz’s extensive and repeated description of the care she and other hostages received in captivity, was quickly criticized by some Israeli PR professionals and commentators as a major Israeli misstep and a propaganda victory for Hamas. While Lifshitz was not directly criticized, the government was blamed by some for failing to oversee the event, and the hospital was blamed by others for arranging it.
https://www.timesofisrael.com/ministry-issues-protocol-for-treatment-of-freed-captives-after-press-event-slammed/amp/
tragically mistaken for surrendering natives yet again! https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/israeli-troops-killed-hostages-mistaking-their-cries-help-ambush-military-2023-12-28/
They certainly not gonna haul it back to US…! So another donation to Israel and they most likely set it up again at Gaza shore to continue atrocities against Palestinians…!
The original intention. I have read that the floating pier was Netanyahu's idea.
I rather suspect it was the idea of some genius in the Pentagon and suggested to Biden as a good PR opportunity, while probably the real intent was to get that unusable white elephant out of inventory in the hopes that Hamas or the IDF would destroy it. It was built in 2007, and I could only find one instance of it being used in all that time, for a war game with Honduras in 2013. It's been in storage all the rest of the time.
I don't think Israel wants this piece of crap, unless to sink it and use it for a breakwater. It becomes unusable with waves only 2 feet tall. It was built in 2007 by a company in Wisconsin, in a port where waves often reach higher than two feet so everyone involved knew from the beginning that it was junk and wouldn't serve the purpose it was designated for. The Pentagram hasn't tried to use it even for war games since 2013.
The so called "Greatest Nation on Earth" can't build a Pier? Really, I don't think so. This failure was intended to STALL and KILL more Palestinians for the Zionist THUGS. Everything being done by the USA/Israel, is a combined effort by Blinken/Netanyahu, to commit GENOCIDE, destroy Gaza. Blinken/Netanyahu marriage is sealed with the Blood of Palestinians and need to be charged with Crimes against Humanity ASAP, arrested ASAP and jailed ASAP. The World needs to see JUSTICE for Palestinians, or we will see other countries follow the example of Israel, thinking they too can commit Genocide.
Mission Accomplished! The floating pier did what it was intended. Operation Incinerate and Behead Palesinian children succeeded beyond all expectations. With 280 dead, 700+ wounded, to extract 4 (while killing 3) hostages, it was a wonderful, heroic mission. Boy, we sure showed those women and children in their tents. I say "we" because we provided logistical and other assistance. A great joint mission!
The Biden administration is floating away in a storm…
To be replaced by Trump. "Finish the job" Trump, will give Israel whatever they want.
That’s right. You put him there.